Jacqueline Kulle
Really Responding
1. "Really Responding" surprised me because it provided many beneficial ways to peer review someone else's work. It taught me to explain my comments, be clear, etc. This article has helped me learn more on how to be a better peer reviewer.
2. Yes, I think the strategies in this text can help in peer reviews. One strategy that stuck out to me is to not be short and sweet when making comments. As a reviewer, you have to leave detailed remarks, giving the writer ways to improve his or her paper. Leaving unclear and short messages will not benefit the writer in any way. Leaving detailed feedback gives the writer more to work with, and will help them improve their work. Another technique this article explained was how to present your comments on a writer's work. Asking questions and offering advice will be very beneficial to the writer. It is also to explain the reasoning for your comments, so they may want to change their paper based on the reading you provide.
3. Yes, I have done peer review in the past. The past experiences have been positive. I enjoy trying to help others improve their writing and others look over mine and give me advice. It turns out to be beneficial to everyone, and I think it is good to get a second opinion.
Really Responding
1. "Really Responding" surprised me because it provided many beneficial ways to peer review someone else's work. It taught me to explain my comments, be clear, etc. This article has helped me learn more on how to be a better peer reviewer.
2. Yes, I think the strategies in this text can help in peer reviews. One strategy that stuck out to me is to not be short and sweet when making comments. As a reviewer, you have to leave detailed remarks, giving the writer ways to improve his or her paper. Leaving unclear and short messages will not benefit the writer in any way. Leaving detailed feedback gives the writer more to work with, and will help them improve their work. Another technique this article explained was how to present your comments on a writer's work. Asking questions and offering advice will be very beneficial to the writer. It is also to explain the reasoning for your comments, so they may want to change their paper based on the reading you provide.
3. Yes, I have done peer review in the past. The past experiences have been positive. I enjoy trying to help others improve their writing and others look over mine and give me advice. It turns out to be beneficial to everyone, and I think it is good to get a second opinion.
Comments
Post a Comment