Sydney Meyer
01/25/18
#1. In the past while I revised peoples work I would be short and sweet on the paper but when handing it back to them I would explain what I meant. thinking about it know if I did that when thy go back to revise their work they may not remember what I explained. therefore, it make sense to provide more information then you think necessary.
#2. When the author said don't be supportive and give the writer the benefit of the doubt it stuck with me because when people read my writing I want them to tell me the truth and not say "oh its great" or "I don't think you need to change anything" I know there are issues with my writing that's why I'm asking your opinion so please tell me what you think. Also, I liked how he said don't try to sound like a teacher just sound like your normal self. I like this because if someone is reviewing my paper I want them to tell me what they think rather then tell me what to do.
#3. I have done peer review in the past and if it is a grade to peer review someone's paper people usually just do the are minimum to get the grade and don't actually give me advice on my papers so I would say its been negative in that situation. Now, if I am just asking someone to read my paper it has been positive because they will actually read my paper and give me good advice to improve my writing.
01/25/18
#1. In the past while I revised peoples work I would be short and sweet on the paper but when handing it back to them I would explain what I meant. thinking about it know if I did that when thy go back to revise their work they may not remember what I explained. therefore, it make sense to provide more information then you think necessary.
#2. When the author said don't be supportive and give the writer the benefit of the doubt it stuck with me because when people read my writing I want them to tell me the truth and not say "oh its great" or "I don't think you need to change anything" I know there are issues with my writing that's why I'm asking your opinion so please tell me what you think. Also, I liked how he said don't try to sound like a teacher just sound like your normal self. I like this because if someone is reviewing my paper I want them to tell me what they think rather then tell me what to do.
#3. I have done peer review in the past and if it is a grade to peer review someone's paper people usually just do the are minimum to get the grade and don't actually give me advice on my papers so I would say its been negative in that situation. Now, if I am just asking someone to read my paper it has been positive because they will actually read my paper and give me good advice to improve my writing.
Comments
Post a Comment